Georgie Porgie’s Menu

WiscoGood Food

Georgie Porgie’s menu is full of delicious burgers and sandwiches and favorite Wisconsin custard stand desserts including sundaes and hand-spun shakes.

We pride ourselves on serving local ingredients when possible, from the Pretzilla buns, to the mozzarella cheese used in our hand-rolled mozza sticks, to the custard made fresh daily from locally-sourced milk and eggs. Even our craft sodas, made with real sugar syrups, are made locally.

Georgie Porgies Serving Locally Made Ingredients

Burgers & Sandwiches

Make it how you like it - bun, patty, toppings
Burger of the Month - Notcho Mama

Signature Burgers

Choose from a single or double signature beef patty, grilled or crispy chicken or a veggie patty on your choice of a locally-baked white, wheat or pretzel bun.

Porgie

Porgie sauce, American cheese, lettuce, pickles & onions.

Shroomy

Sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, gourmet mayo & onions.

Pizzahhh

Crispy mozza stick, provolone cheese, marinara sauce, Parmesan cheese, Italian herbs & side of pepperoncini.

Cowboy

Hickory smoked bacon, aged cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, shredded lettuce & tomato.

Georgie Porgies Cowboy Burger

Jalapeno Popper

Cheddar, fresh jalapenos, sauteed onions, cream cheese, o-rings & a jalapeno popper.

Guacamole

Guacamole, hickory smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato & onion.

Cheddar Melt

Loads of Wisconsin cheddar cheese & fried onions on buttered toast.

BYO Burger

Pick your toppings: ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickle, mayo, onions.

Burger of the Month - Notcho Mama

Pretzel Series

Some of our most popular sandwiches, served on a locally-baked Pretzilla bun.

Beer Cheese & Bacon

Homemade Wisconsin beer cheese made with Spotted Cow Beer, hickory smoked bacon & fried onions on a pretzel bun.

Mac & Chz Burger

Premium white cheddar mac & cheese, wisco cheddar & bacon on a pretzel bun.

Malibu Chicken

Smoked ham, aged Swiss, lettuce, tomato & choice of gourmet mayo or side honey mustard on a pretzel bun.

Georgie Porgies Mac n cheeze burger
Georgie Porgies Burgers and Custard Menu

Custard

Sundaes

Funky Monkey

Vanilla custard, peanut butter cup, fresh bananas, hot fudge, whipped cream & cherry

Banana Cream Pie

Vanilla custard, banana pudding, graham cracker, fresh banana slices, whipped cream & cherry

Sundae of the Month - Dirt Cake

Choco Pretzel Mania

Vanilla custard, salted pretzel pieces, peanut butter cups, hot fudge, whipped cream & cherry

SMores

Twist custard, marshmallows, chocolate flakes, hot fudge, marshmallow cream, graham crackers, whipped cream & cherry

Grasshopper

Vanilla custard, Oreos, hot fudge, Creme de Menthe, whipped cream & cherry

Flavor of the Day

Georgie Porgies Flavor of the Day - Chocolate Malt Crunch

Blitzes

Georgie Porgies Oreo Blitz

Our original custard recipe, thickened and blended with your choice of one of over 25 toppings:

Strawberries – Banana – Blueberry – Cherries – Pineapple – Raspberries
Chocolate syrup – Hot caramel – Hot fudge – Marshmallow – Cream Mint Topping – Peanut butter – Cookie dough – Oreo – Heath – M&M – Snickers Peanut butter cup – Colored sprinkles – Graham crackers – Cake pieces – Brownie pieces – Salted pretzels – Choco flakes

Additional toppings with additional charge available – Pecans – Crushed nuts

Shakes & Malts

Georgie Porgies Chocolate Shake

Our original custard hand-dipped and spun to order with one of 25 toppings added in.

Strawberries – Banana – Blueberry – Cherries – Pineapple – Raspberries – Chocolate syrup – Hot caramel – Hot fudge – Marshmallow – Cream mint topping – Peanut butter – Cookie dough – Oreo – Heath – M&M – Snickers Peanut butter cup – Colored sprinkles – Graham crackers – Cake pieces – Brownie pieces – Salted pretzels – Choco flakes

Additional toppings with additional charge available – Pecans – Crushed nuts

Salads & Pitas

Greek Chicken Salad

Kalamata olives, pepperoncini, feta cheese, diced tomatoes & red onions served on organic spring mix and topped with our house-made Greek dressing. Choose from crispy or grilled chicken.

Chicken Caesar Salad

Organic spring mix, your choice of grilled or crispy chicken, Parmesan cheese, diced tomatoes & red onions topped with our house-made Caesar dressing.

Apple Pecan Salad

Fresh apples, roasted pecans, diced tomatoes & red onions on a bed of organic spring mix served with our house-made Raspberry Vinaigrette.

Chicken Garden Salad

Organic spring mix topped with your choice of grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, red onion, mushrooms and cheddar cheese served with your favorite house-made dressing (we love it with Ranch dressing).

Georgie Porgies Gyro Plate Platter
Georgie Porgies Greek Chicken Salad

Gyro Plate Platter

Fresh carved rotisserie gyro meat topped with onion and tomato and homemade sauce on the side.

Chicken Pita Dinner w/Salad

Strips of fresh chicken breast marinated then grilled with a splash of white wine topped with onion and tomato and homemade sauce on the side.

Georgie Porgies Gyro Plate Platter

Kids Meals

Treefort Favorites Right-Sized For Our Youngest Guests

Children 12 and under can choose from the following meals, each served with their choice of freshly-sliced apples or premium cut fries and their choice of milk or a locally-crafted soda:

Chicken Branches – real chicken fried in zero trans-fat oil

Grilled Cheese – made with real Wisconsin cheese

Cheeseburger – made to their liking and served on a white or wheat bun

Corn Dog Bites – Wisconsin fair favorite in bite sizes

Georgie Porgies Kids Meals

Savory Sides

Georgie Porgies Moxx Sticks

4-Piece Mozzarella Sticks

Homemade wonton wrapped mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce.

Onion Rings

Thick-cut, beer-battered onion rings and crisped to perfection.

4-Piece Chicken Tenders

Chicken tenders lightly breaded.

Fried Cheese Curds

Squeaky cheese curds in our very own breading, dipped in 0 trans-fat oil.

Cheese Fries

Simply put, our premium cut fries doused in nacho cheese sauce.

Fries

Premium shoestring fries cut from Wisconsin-grown potatoes.

Drinks

Custom-Crafted Sodas

Locally-made custom-crafted sodas including our own Root Beer.

Treeforts Are Awesome
Georgie Porgies Custom Crafter Sodas

Catering Menu

Cater your next party, luncheon or event!

Your party, business luncheon or event just got tastier! Let Georgie Porgie’s cater your group get-together. Even better, we offer optional delivery with all catering orders. Online ordering is now available or contact the restaurant manager at your nearest location to arrange a catering order or special request.

Pita Party

Choice of rotisserie gyro, grilled chicken, or mixed grilled seasonal veggies. Onions, tomatoes, and homemade cucumber sauce on the side.

Italian Beef

Finely sliced Italian beef in aujus. Fresh french bread, pepperoncinis & a provolone cheese platter on the side.

BBQ Pork

Pulled pork smothered in BBQ sauce. Fresh baked buns and pickle spears on the side. Great with side cole slaw.

Burger Bonanza

Choice of fresh grilled beef burgers, veggie garden burgers or grilled chicken. Comes with a sliced Wisconsin cheese platter. Choose between a white or wheat bun.

Sides

Garden Salad, Greek Salad, Caesar Salad, Apple Pecan Salad, Coleslaw, Chips

Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Bottled Water

Desserts

Variety of frozen custard available in quarts. Each Quart feeds around 6 people. Dishes and spoons are provided.

Georgie Porgies Serving Locally Made Ingredients

Prices are per person. Includes all cutlery, plates and napkins. A 24 hour notice is recommended. Orders placed within 24 hours will be assessed a $20 rush service fee should we be able to accommodate. Delivery and setup are offered at an additional $20 within 15 miles. If you reside outside of 15 miles, contact our management team. Chafers are offered at an additional $10 each.